Skip to content

Unnecessary check of isActive in Maneuvers/Maneuver consumes #170

Description

@krisgry

Hi,
Did some digging in the Maneuvers/Maneuver, and found that bind is defined such that the consume function is only called if the task is active:

bind(T* task_obj, bool always = false)
{
if (always)
{
Task::bind<M>(task_obj);
}
else
{
void (Maneuver::* func)(const M*) = &Maneuver::consumeIfActive<M, T>;
Task::bind<M>(this, func);
}
}

Then I discovered that the consume functions of PathControlState and StopManeuver still check if the task is active:

Maneuver::consume(const IMC::PathControlState* pcs)
{
if (!isActive())
return;

and
Maneuver::consume(const IMC::StopManeuver* sm)
{
(void)sm;
if (isActive())
{
requestDeactivation();
IMC::ManeuverControlState mcs;
mcs.state = IMC::ManeuverControlState::MCS_STOPPED;
mcs.info = "stopped";
mcs.eta = 0;
dispatch(mcs);
}

which should not be necessary (unless I'm missing something?).

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions