Skip to content

wrap-authorization ignores 'raised' unauthorized exceptions in async mode #88

Description

@mszajna

With Ring 3-arity contract, exceptions thrown in the same thread bubble back to the middleware. However, if any non-blocking IO was to happen between wrap-authorization and throw-unauthorized, those exceptions would arrive via raise callback. One such instance could be a OAuth2 authorization backend calling the token endpoint. A simplified example:

(defn handler [request respond raise]
  (future ; simulates non-blocking IO switching threads
    (try
      (throw-unauthorized) ; simplified example
      (catch Throwable t (raise t))))) ; raise any handler exceptions per Ring spec

(-> handler
    (wrap-authorization nil) ; backend doesn't get called anyway
    (apply {:request-method :get} println println nil)) ; run it
; => #ExceptionInfo
; expected: wrap-authorization to catch the raised exception
; and handle it with the backend

Possible fix

(defn wrap-authorization
  (fn
    ; [...]
    ([request respond raise]
     (try (handler request respond
           (fn [e] (try (respond (authorization-error request e backend))
                     (catch Throwable t (raise t))))
          (catch Exception e
            (respond (authorization-error request e backend)))))))

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions