finding(skills): 预挂 needs:contract-review 在 2026-08-28 裁定后持续复发——两日 9 例,分诊/执行席的定级流程文本未吸收「可复审增量存在前永不挂标」

[zhuangjianguo]

Filed unassigned by 项目总监席(session session_01DxbNgzPMo4YuRBmGmCQp9m),仅记录,交 skills 车道定级。

事实

维护者 2026-08-28 对 #12887 裁定:needs:contract-review 仅在可复审增量(PR,或先到的报告)存在时挂载;队列/受阻卡的预挂废止(细则单源 .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/contract-review.md 「⛔ 不预挂」段)。

裁定后两日,总监席复审勤务两轮共摘除 9 例预挂(全部为定级/认领时挂标、无任何增量):

• 2026-08-30 轮:os#13347 · ui#6781 · ui#6776(认领评论自述「needs:contract-review applied」于认领时)
• 2026-08-31 轮:os#13540 · os#13539 · os#13531 · os#13405 · os#13216(分诊定级评论自述「触条款② PATH 肢 ⇒ needs:contract-review」于定级时,卡态 pm:queue)

每例摘除评论均引裁定原文并注明「PR 存在的同笔即重挂」。复发的成本:复审席每轮扫到不可审载体空耗一遍(本席两轮各花一趟排除),且标签宣称「真实待审」为假,腐蚀载体=待审的机读语义。

根因假设(待 skills 席核)

定级席与执行席的流程文本(分诊 SOP / 认领模板)在「条款②判定」步骤旁仍写着或暗示「同笔挂 needs:contract-review」——判定(裁决时点名条款②预期 yes)与挂载(增量存在时)两个动作没有在文本上分开。修法方向:在相应 SOP 的条款②段落写明「判定记录在卡,标签由 PR 创建者在开 PR 的同笔挂」,并引 2026-08-28 裁定。

⛔ 本卡不改任何 skill 文本(governed 面,归 skills 车道);仅记录实例与方向。

Refs: #12887(裁定载体)· references/contract-review.md 不预挂段 · 9 例摘除评论(各卡时间线可查)。

[zhuangjianguo]

定级(skills 车道自分诊):Task · priority:p2 · pm:queue · domain:skills

复发 9 例是对 2026-08-28 裁定的持续违反,成本为复审席每轮空耗一趟 + 标签机读语义腐蚀 ⇒ 高于 p3;无错误合并、无正确性伤害 ⇒ 非 p1。升 p1 条件:一次预挂导致真实待审载体被跳过或误处置。

采卡的根因方向:修法落在定级/认领流程文本的条款②段 —— 把「判定(裁决时点名条款②预期)」与「挂载(增量存在时,由开 PR 的同笔挂)」两个动作在文本上分开,并引 2026-08-28 裁定原文;references/contract-review.md 的「⛔ 不预挂」段为单源,只加指针不复制细则。

入队不即派(面持):候选落点 SKILL.md 认领模板段(被候批 PR #13505 持有)与 dispatch-runbook.md(被在飞 #13304 持有)⇒ 排两者之后;届时与同面卡按五门判折叠。

---

Generated by Claude Code

[zhuangjianguo]

Hypothesis VERIFIED — this card survives the value gate and stays queued: it is a correction of text that contradicts a standing ruling, not an addition.

Measured on origin/main 9c120f030: SKILL.md:758 reads 「派发席职责止于:卡上记一行认定、挂 needs:contract-review(标签命名审的对象,恒英文)、…」 — the dispatch seat's clause-② duty as written INSTRUCTS same-stroke hanging, exactly what the 2026-08-28 ruling abolished. references/contract-review.md:43 pulls the same direction (「条款②的 mode:subagent 派发照旧恒保留 needs:contract-review」) against that file's own :10 ⛔不预挂. The 9 measured recurrences trace to live text, not to seats ignoring text.

Scope when dispatched: in-place correction of SKILL.md:758 (判定记卡;挂载随可复审增量,由 PR 创建者同笔) plus reconciliation of contract-review.md:43 with its own :10 — word-level, net ≤0 lines. Serial: SKILL.md is held by PR #13505's chain; this card is next on that face after it clears. Explicitly NOT frozen into audit #13597 — ruling-contradiction corrections keep flowing; the freeze is for additions.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[zhuangjianguo]

Claim: PM loop round 5 — dispatch on the SKILL.md face freed by PR #13505's merge (per the verification comment above: correction class, explicitly not frozen by audit #13597)
Session: session_01EXxTW8mvPBhoHxmyPZ63de
Branch: claude/issue-13557-no-prehang-correction
Worktree: objectstack-issue-13557
Domain: domain:skills
File surface: .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md (the :758 派发席职责 sentence — position re-verified at 09b0d7b95, still :758 post-#13505) + .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/contract-review.md (:43 vs :10 reconciliation — READ first; edit only if :43 is measured to instruct label-timing rather than requirement-retention) ONLY. ⛔ scripts/pm/check-skill-line-ratchet.mjs untouched (pin moves ride audit #13597 Phase 3). Stop on breach; explain in the report.
Container & model: M, mode:subagent, model: fable — dispatch-gates --tier at 09b0d7b95: "Model tier — MANDATORY: claude-fable-5 … clause ① — the PM dispatch skill MAIN file is the lane's own operating protocol and a wrong edit propagates to every later dispatch". No exit taken: judgment-bearing protocol semantics (the grading/labeling duty sentence), not a mechanical one-liner.
Clause-②: yes | no — no (process/label text; no contract accept/reject behavior touched)
Serial constraints cleared: SKILL.md face freed by PR #13505's merge (02:44Z; this card was recorded next on that face). contract-review.md has no in-flight holder (#13417 parked pm:on-hold; its blocked branch stands but is not active). Retirement flight delivered (dispatch-runbook only); half-states PR armed (scripts only). Line budget: net ≤0 REQUIRED on both files (SKILL.md 960, this is a correction not an addition; contract-review.md 48/48 headroom 0 hard). H17: no intersection. Batch 2/3.

---

Generated by Claude Code