[Decision] platform-readings.md ceiling 359/362 → 385/388 for the fifth readings increment (PR #16379, red on the ratchet by design) — and whether a standing rule replaces per-increment ceiling cards for this ledger

[claude]

维护者速读(skills 席代读)

事情:平台读数账本 references/platform-readings.md 的第五次增量(PR #16379)按您定的规矩落成 26 行、故意在行数棘轮上红着等您裁。上限现在 359(PR #15955 您合并后 362);增量是 +26,一条一行,账本里没有可删的行,折行不算货币。这是今天第二次为同一个文件请您抬上限(上一次 #15960,您裁了 A)。

选项

• A 上限抬到实测数:359 → 385(若 docs(pm-dispatch): three measured platform readings into the readings ledger #15955 先合并,362 → 388,同一个 +26)。补丁轮同 docs(pm-dispatch): three measured platform readings into the readings ledger #15955:上限行 + ruledRaises 记录 + PR 正文引用本裁决。
• B 裁一个更小的数,把增量退回去砍:席位得点名删掉哪些已量到的事实。
• C 就地付账删旧行:没有候选——账本每一行都是还在用的读数。

再问一句(可与 A 一起答):这类「席位逐条核过、查重过的平台读数增量」以后是否改为常设规则——每次增量按实测行数抬上限、记进 ruledRaises,不再逐次立决策卡?

• 甲 维持现状:每次抬上限都立卡请您裁(人工地板「抬 ratchet 上限」照旧)。
• 乙 只对这一个账本文件开一条常设规则:增量须由席位在验收评论里逐条核过、查重过、一条一行;上限随之抬到落地数并记 ruledRaises;其余文件不变。

席位意见:A + 乙。四轴:业务——账本是舰队每天查的操作表,把量到的事实挡在门外只会让它们退回各席位的记忆;长远——乙把「抬上限」的判据写成可核的形状(核过、查重过、一条一行),比逐次裁更稳定;防 AI 错——每条新行都是收紧(一个 agent 不能再假设的读数),不是放权,而棘轮本意防的「小功能大扩写」在这里由席位的逐条核验替代;创业阶段——少一类决策卡,零新机制。若您更愿意逐次看,答 A + 甲 也完全可行。

你要做的:回 A/B/C,再回 甲/乙。

---

Governing text: the SKILL.md gate row 「抬上限需维护者裁决引用在 PR 正文」 and the human floor 「人工地板同含:…门禁削弱(降阈值、删必查项、抬 ratchet 上限、跳过测试)」 (SKILL.md 分诊座位职责); the ratchet map's own docblock (ruledRaises: one record per ordinary ruled raise, quoting the ruling); the 2026-08-17 ruling that re-wrap is not currency; #15960's ruling A (2026-09-06 14:10Z, comment 5559776878) as the precedent.

四棱块

① 事实 PR #16379 (57cd6389d6) adds 26 lines to platform-readings.md (359 → 385), zero deletions, every line ≤120 bytes, register clean; the dedup ran against PR #15955's head (48 candidates: 25 landed as 26 lines, 11 present, 12 declined); the line ratchet is red on this one file only; every other gate green; merge-tree clean against PR #15955. The ceiling is 359 on main, 362 after PR #15955 (ruled A on #15960 today).

② 分叉 A raise to the measured count (385 / 388) · B a smaller number and a cut · C pay in place by deleting existing lines. Plus the standing-rule fork: 甲 per-increment cards as now · 乙 a standing rule for this one ledger file (seat-verified, deduplicated, one line per fact ⇒ the ceiling follows the landed count, recorded in ruledRaises).

③ 各支的代价 A: +26 on a file whose every line is a consulted reading; the map-wide total stays down (the ratchet's own move accounting). B: the seat names facts to drop — each a measured reading the fleet paid for. C: no candidate exists; a deletion would remove a live reading. 甲: one decision card per increment (two today). 乙: the human floor for this file's raises moves to a written seat procedure — the check is the seat's verdict comment, which the director's governed audit reads.

④ 需要裁决者提供的东西 One letter for the ceiling (A / B / C) and one for the rule (甲 / 乙).

Refs #15977, #16006, #15960, PR #16379.

---

Generated by Claude Code