Skip to content

Prototype an App-first paper audit-to-reproduction workshop - #3

Open
MinhMPA wants to merge 11 commits into
deck-starter-packfrom
prototype/ioannidis-app-cli
Open

Prototype an App-first paper audit-to-reproduction workshop#3
MinhMPA wants to merge 11 commits into
deck-starter-packfrom
prototype/ioannidis-app-cli

Conversation

@MinhMPA

@MinhMPA MinhMPA commented Aug 30, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Summary

  • add a private 60-minute Ioannidis App-to-CLI workshop prototype
  • route participant-generated companion, audit, and replication-brief artifacts through every stage
  • pin source PDFs, provenance, independent Table 4 values, and 36 Figure 1 checkpoints
  • provide an intentionally incomplete starter plus a verified Python solution
  • demonstrate the printed Table 2 expression as UNMATCHED and the corrected expression as MATCH

Verification

  • uv sync --locked succeeds
  • solution test suite: 23 passed
  • starter source/oracle/artifact checks: 12 passed
  • reproduction CLI: all Table 4 and Figure 1 checks MATCH; final OVERALL: MATCH
  • independent code review: no remaining Critical or Important findings

Known validation gates

Native Codex App timing, correction discovery in a fresh App task, novice implementation time, and the full participant workshop remain explicitly marked NOT YET TESTED. The paper remains a computationally strong provisional choice until those trials pass.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant